By Marilyn Jozwik
When theatergoers think of comedy, they think of Neil Simon. And when you think of a Neil Simon comedy, you think of “The Odd Couple.
With its 1965 debut on Broadway, the 1968 movie and the 1970s TV series, the play had tons of early exposure and hasn’t stopped being a stage favorite for audiences since.
The full house at Sunset Playhouse for a recent Sunday matinee proved that the long-in-the-tooth comedy still has tremendous appeal.
Directed by Brian Zelinski, the outstanding cast had the audience responding to Simon’s comedy with chuckles, chortles, guffaws, giggles and every other sort of tickle-the-funny-bone sound one could imagine.
Most are familiar with the basic premise of the play. Friends and poker pals Oscar Madison and Felix Unger end up living together in Oscar’s New York City apartment after Felix’s wife kicks him out. Their friendship begins to dissolve when the slovenly Oscar realizes he can’t live with the fastidious Felix. Simon has cleverly added four other poker playing friends as well as a pair of British sisters to optimize the laughter.
The show opens with the four card-playing guests at Oscar’s messy apartment. Oscar is in the kitchen preparing a “buffet” of stale potato chips, warm coke, and brown and green sandwiches. Felix shows up late and distraught with no place to stay, so Oscar agrees to let him stay with him. Keep your ears open because some of Simon’s best dialogue comes in that first scene.
In Act 2, the card players are back, but this time Oscar’s place is spotless. Felix is serving perfectly made sandwiches and insisting everyone use coasters and not leave crumbs, an air purifier is running and the cards have been disinfected. Everyone leaves in disgust, missing the old ways.
Tired of nights at home, Oscar convinces Felix to get together with the two sisters living in their building. The pair end up providing the perfect foils for the friendship and a satisfying ending.
The parts of Oscar and Felix are bucket list roles for many performers, and luckily Sunset snatched a perfect pairing in Mike Owens as the easygoing sportswriter Oscar and Tony Davis as the CBS newsman and neat freak Felix. The contrast is stark – Owens’ Oscar looks relaxed in a loose Mets T-shirt, Felix is wound-tight in a pressed white dress shirt. I loved the scene in which Oscar is standing in one spot talking to a Felix who is in constant motion, in and out of the kitchen, dramatizing how Oscar is perfectly content to live in his mess while Felix cannot sit still until everything is perfect.
Owens’ Oscar keeps an even keel, while Davis’ Felix pouts, cries, and exaggerates his every discomfort. Each maintains every inch of their character and really solicited lots of laughs from the audience as they handled Simon’s fast-paced, witty dialogue with aplomb.
I also enjoyed the poker-playing quartet of Murray (Bob Fuchs), Speed (Karl Miller), Roy (Michael Fantry) and Vinnie (Casey Van Dam) who have great fun with Simon’s lines, like when Fantry’s Roy deadpans to Speed: “Could you do me a favor? Smoke toward New Jersey.” When Oscar joins them, the laughs are compounded.
Tess Cinpinski and Brigid O’Brien as the British sisters add to the humor with delightful portrayals and look fabulous in their bright green and rose dresses, adding pops of color to the set.
The hard-working set is easy on the eyes (save for Oscar’s messes!) and has lots of well-working, well-used doors for Oscar’s eight-room apartment.
Wisconsin’s cold, grey days might be nothing to laugh at, but Sunset’s “The Odd Couple” most certainly is!
If You Go:
Who: Sunset Playhouse
What: “The Odd Couple”
When: Through Feb. 2
Where: 700 Wall St., Elm Grove
Tickets/Info: 262-782-4430; SunsetPlayhouse.com